This Cheryl's cookies review covers the classic buttercream-frosted sugar cookies as well as the brand's lesser-known flavors. And we don't sugarcoat anything, either—they're all just that good.

Nestled in the bustling commercial district of Wilkes-Barre Township, where savvy shoppers congregate and budget-conscious consumers thrive, stands a verdant-canopied haven of thriftiness that has ...